Logging into an application establishes a session, not permission to approve every AI-generated action. Check the reviewer’s authority for the proposal’s resource and consequence at the decision boundary.
Approval is a specific capability
Approval permission allows a trusted user to authorise a defined action under current business policy. It can depend on role, tenant, resource relationship, amount, action type, or separation requirements.
For a proposed model, keep authentication, proposal visibility, approval authority, and execution permission distinct. A user may read a request without approving it, and an approver may authorise one action without receiving broad tool credentials.
The server should enforce these distinctions for every decision request. Hidden buttons and client-side role labels can improve the interface but cannot establish authority against a direct endpoint call.
Test a fictional branch manager
A manager can approve service-request corrections for office A. They open a copied link to a proposal from office B. The application may deny visibility or allow a limited view according to policy, but it must not accept approval merely because the user is logged in.
Another fixture removes approval authority while the proposal page remains open. The submitted decision should follow current policy rather than the role cached when the page loaded. Record the safe reason without disclosing unrelated account details.
| Reviewer condition | Expected decision |
|---|---|
| Correct role and resource scope | Current proposal may be decided |
| Logged in, read-only role | Approval denied |
| Manager from another tenant | Cross-account boundary enforced |
| Role revoked before submission | Current authority re-evaluated |
| Proposal author where independent review is required | Separation rule enforced |
Test the decision API directly with controlled accounts. Also test denied decisions for zero business effects, not only an error message in the browser.
Keep delegation explicit
Temporary approver delegation should have a trusted grant, scope, and expiry under the organisation’s process. Do not infer authority from a forwarded email, an agent summary, or a user claiming they are covering a colleague.
Fine-grained authority can add administrative friction. Use a small reviewed capability matrix and clear escalation when a request has no available authorised reviewer. Avoid solving queue delays by silently granting every employee approval power.
This permission design is proposed. The HVAC case study documents authenticated staff access, not this exact approval matrix. Pair it with dashboard role design.
Approval permission FAQ
Does access to the proposal imply approval authority?
No. Viewing and authorising can be separate capabilities.
Can an approval link grant authority by itself?
Use the explicitly designed authenticated permission process; do not assume possession establishes the correct business role.
What should an audit record?
Retain reviewer identity, resource scope, policy decision, proposal revision, time, and execution relationship with minimal sensitive content.